A Historic Landmark



Historic Hotel

Built in 1892, this Queen Anne style hotel stands as one of Wisconsin’s longest continually operating hotel.  



Hotel Laack

In its earliest years, formerly known as the Hotel Laack, the hotel was the go-to choice for travelers. It was built across from the Plymouth Cheese Exchange on a route leading to the Chicago and North Western depot. The hotel quickly became a favorite among the traveling cheese salesmen, and still serves as such today.

From Wisconsin Historical Society


Hotel Mitchell & 52 Stafford

After a fire nearly destroyed the hotel, it was rebuilt in 1921 and eventually sold to Edward Mitchell in 1943, where it operated as Hotel Mitchell until 1979.

In 1985, 52 Stafford made its name as Wisconsin’s Historic Irish hotel.

From Sheboygan Press



The Fig and the Pheasant

The business was purchased on October 7th, 2019 by Patrick and Ronna O’Toole. Their hospitality-driven vision focuses on the guests and the experience at the hotel.

Ronna and Patrick met in 1998, in Northern California, when they competed against each other for the same position in a hotel kitchen.  Fortunately for them they were both hired and as they say the rest is an amazing history of love, food, travel, and adventure.  Together they have worked alongside each other in renowned hotels & restaurants in breathtaking parts of the world.  Their careers have brought them and their young daughter, Quintessa, to the Island of Nevis in The Caribbean, to above the Arctic Circle in Norway.  There in Oslo, their son Liam was born and they began work in The 5 star Grand Hotel.  Then it was on to Dubai, to Hong Kong, and then back to the United States again as Director of Food Services for the historic Osthoff Resort in Elkhart Lake, WI and finally as the chefs and owners of The Fig & The Pheasant in beautiful downtown Plymouth, Wisconsin, Cheese Capital of the World.

It should then come as no surprise that they should desire to take over a historic boutique hotel, rename it The Fig and The Pheasant, focus on their guests and offer them flavorful seasonal cocktails, fine wines, approachable seasonal cuisine interspersed with herbs and edible flowers for breakfast, cocktail hour, & dinner.  It’s worth it to stop in the European styled bar for a drink and mouthwatering appetizer as you listen to these two recount with jests and laughter tales from their kitchens past and present.


Historic Rooms

We invite you to experience all the beauty that is The Fig & the Pheasant. Take a peek inside our historic rooms and see what all the buzz is about!

View Rooms

Start typing and press Enter to search